Last Updated on November 16, 2026 by Kiersten James
If you grew up on Long Island, you know the white bakery box tied with string. Every Christmas Eve one showed up on somebody’s table, packed with rainbow cookies, pignoli, and those little jam-filled butter cookies with the sprinkled ends.
Those trays cost a small fortune now.
I spent years remaking these cookies in my own kitchen, over and over (and over), until they tasted like the ones from our local Italian bakeries and bagel stores.
Here’s my whole Long Island Italian Christmas cookie tray in one place. Bake a few or bake them all, then freeze them or box them up and give them away. That’s the best part anyway!
How to Build an Italian Christmas Cookie Tray
The Cookies
1. Italian Rainbow Cookies

Dense almond layers, raspberry jam and a chocolate top, just like the ones from Long Island bagel stores. They take a little time, but they are absolutely worth it.
Get the Italian Rainbow Cookies recipe →
2. Italian Pignoli Cookies

Chewy almond-paste cookies covered in pine nuts. Only a handful of ingredients, and they make any tray look like it came from the bakery.
Get the Italian Pignoli Cookies recipe →
3. Italian Ricotta Cookies

Soft, cakey cookies with a sweet glaze and sprinkles. They’re light, they’re pretty, and they disappear very fast.
Get the Italian Ricotta Cookies recipe →
4. Jam-Filled Italian Butter Cookies

Almond butter cookies sandwiched with raspberry jam, then dipped in chocolate and sprinkles. These are the classic Italian bakery butter cookies you’ll find in the plastic clamshell containers in any deli, bagel store, or grocery store.
Get the Jam-Filled Italian Butter Cookies recipe →
5. Almond Cherry Macaroons (Amaretti all’Amarena)

Soft, chewy almond cookies made with almond paste and cherries. They’re flourless and naturally gluten-free, which is handy when you’re feeding a crowd.
Get the Almond Cherry Macaroons (Amaretti all’Amarena) recipe →
6. Italian Anise Biscotti

Crisp, twice-baked biscotti flavored with anise, from a 100-year-old family recipe. Put out a pot of coffee and these are GONE.
Get the Italian Anise Biscotti recipe →
7. Italian Christmas Cookies (Lemon Drop Cookies)

Soft, bakery-style lemon cookies with a white glaze. Simple, bright, and a nice break from all the chocolate.
Get the Italian Christmas Cookies (Lemon Drop Cookies) recipe →
8. New York Black and White Cookies

Not Italian, but you’ll find them in literally every tri-state bakery and bagel store. Big, soft and cakey, with half vanilla and half chocolate icing.
Get the New York Black and White Cookies recipe →
9. Checkerboard Icebox Cookies

Classic New York bakery-style slice-and-bake cookies. Make the dough ahead, keep it in the fridge, and bake when you’re ready.
Get the Checkerboard Icebox Cookies recipe →
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make Italian Christmas cookies ahead of time?
Yes. The sturdier cookies, like biscotti, rainbow cookies and checkerboard cookies, are the best ones to make early. Check each recipe card for its storage and freezing notes.
What’s the difference between almond paste and marzipan?
Almond paste has more almonds and less sugar than marzipan. Pignoli and amaretti need almond paste, don’t swap in marzipan.
How many kinds of cookies should go on a tray?
Four or five kinds makes a full, bakery-looking tray. Pick a mix of chewy, crisp and glazed cookies, and at least one with chocolate.
Want even more? See my Ultimate Christmas Cookie Tray for all of the classic American Christmas cookies!
